Major FL Court: Respondent Committed “Repeat Violence” Against Petitioner… Here’s Why

November 16, 2026 Criminal Defense, Violent Crimes

Florida’s 4th District Court of Appeal concluded that a respondent engaged in repeat violence for injunction purposes – as the two acts of violence alleged by the petitioner were sufficiently separated by time, not part of the same incident.

CASE: Levy v. Jacobs, 69 So.3d 403 (Fla. 4th DCA 2011)

Charge(s): Repeat Violence Injunction

Outcome: Injunction AFFIRMED, as the respondent engaged in two courses of violent conduct, qualifying the petitioner for a permanent injunction against repeat violence.

Stalking and Aggravated Stalking in Florida

Stalking and aggravated stalking are serious offenses in Florida that can carry significant legal and financial penalties. Stalking occurs when a person willfully, maliciously, and repeatedly follows, harasses, or cyberstalks another person. Florida Statutes Section 784.048(2) regulates the offense of stalking.

If someone has been accused of stalking by harassing the victim, the State must establish that the defendant engaged in a course of conduct directed at the victim that:

  • Served no legitimate purpose
  • Would cause substantial emotional distress to a reasonable person
  • Did cause substantial emotional distress to the victim

If charged criminally, stalking is a first-degree misdemeanor – punishable by up to 1 year in jail and a $1,000 fine. Cyberstalking carries the same criminal penalties as stalking, and occurs when someone does either of the following:

  • Engages in a course of conduct to communicate words, images, or language through electronic methods, either directly or indirectly, which is directed at or pertaining to a targeted person; or
  • Accesses, or attempts to access, the online account or internet-connected home electronic system without a specified person’s consent – which causes substantial emotional distress to the victim 

Note: For purposes of stalking, substantial emotional distress connotes an unjustifiable infliction of stress of great proportion, in the nature of “fear and concern.” Kaye v. Wilson, 363 So.3d 1155 (Fla. 2d DCA 2023)

Stalking is an enhanceable offense, meaning that certain forms of stalking are felonies and carry heavier criminal penalties under Florida law. For example:

  • Someone who makes a credible threat to the victim in the course of stalking commits a third-degree felony, punishable by up to 5 years in prison and a $5,000 fine
  • Someone who stalks a victim 16 years old or younger commits a third-degree felony, punishable by up to 5 years in prison and a $5,000 fine
  • Someone who violates an existing injunction against stalking commits aggravated stalking, a third-degree felony punishable by up to 5 years in prison and a $5,000 fine

Note: A police officer may make a warrantless arrest of anyone they suspect of stalking based on probable cause. 

Under Florida law, stalking must be done both willfully and maliciously. “Willfully” is defined as knowingly, intentionally, and purposely. “Maliciously” is defined as wrongfully, intentionally, and without lawful justification or excuse. Seese v. State, 955 So. 2d 1145 (Fla. 4th DCA 2007) 

In addition to stalking, there is aggravated stalking. Aggravated stalking includes the elements of stalking, but with the added requirement of making a credible threat to the victim, or violating an injunction for protection against violence. 

Aggravated stalking is a third-degree felony punishable by up to 5 years in prison and a $5,000 fine. Moreover, under Florida Statutes Section 784.048, a court may issue an order restraining the defendant in an aggravated stalking case from contacting the victim for up to 10 years.

In addition to a criminal charge, someone may be subject to a stalking INJUNCTION. In Florida, an injunction is defined as a court order that is meant to compel a person to engage in – or refrain from engaging in – a particular course of conduct (e.g. to stay away from a person).

There are two broad types of stalking injunctions – temporary injunctions and permanent (final) injunctions. A temporary injunction (also known as an ex parte injunction) can be entered before the respondent (e.g. the party accused of stalking) gets a full hearing. The process proceeds in the following way:

  • The petitioner files a verified petition alleging stalking
  • The judge reviews the petition – generally, the respondent does not have to be present
  • If it appears that stalking exists, the court may issue a temporary injunction pending a full hearing
  • Temporary injunctions ordinarily last no more than 15 days
  • A full hearing must be scheduled no later than the date of expiration of the temporary injunction
  • However, the hearing on the final injunction may be continued (e.g. delayed) for GOOD CAUSE, such as inability to obtain service on the respondent (and a temporary injunction may be extended accordingly)

There are various types of injunctions that may be issued in Florida – depending on the facts of the case. These include:

  • Injunction for protection for domestic violence – Under Fla. Stat. 741.30, this may issue if the petitioner and respondent presently reside together, have lived together in the past in an intimate or family relationship, are related by blood/marriage OR share a child
  • Injunction for protection from repeat violence – May be issued when a party proves that at least 2 instances of stalking and/or violence have been committed against them by the respondent in the last 6 months and the petitioner/respondent do not have a relationship qualifying them for a domestic violence injunction
  • Injunction for protection from dating violence – requires that 1) the dating relationship existed within the last 6 months; 2) the nature of the relationship is characterized by the expectation of affection or sexual involvement between the parties; and 3) the frequency and type of interaction is based on the party’s involvement over time and on a continuous basis during the course of the relationship
  • Injunction for sexual violence – requires a victim or parent of a victim to establish that 1) the petitioner has reported the alleged sexual violence to a law enforcement agency and is cooperating in any criminal proceeding against the respondent; and 2) the respondent who committed sexual violence was sentenced to a term of imprisonment in state prison, and the term of imprisonment has expired or is due to expire within 90 days following the date the petition is filed

If a trial judge receives a petition for an injunction against stalking, repeat violence, or domestic or dating violence in Florida, that judge can do one of three things:

  • DENY the petition outright on the basis that the allegations against the respondent are legally insufficient to support the issuance of an injunction – and decline to schedule a final hearing 
  • DENY the petition on the basis that there is currently insufficient evidence for even a temporary injunction to issue – but schedule a hearing to determine whether there is a sufficient legal basis to issue a final injunction (e.g. based on the evidence/testimony)
  • GRANT the petition and issue a temporary injunction until a final hearing is held – at which point the judge will determine whether the injunction should become permanent

In the event that a hearing is scheduled, both the petitioner and the respondent will have a chance to do the following:

  • Present evidence to corroborate their account/dispute the opposing party’s 
  • Offer testimony
  • Call witnesses, if necessary, to support their argument(s)

It is important to note that at an injunction hearing, the burden of proof differs from a criminal trial. The distinction is as follows:

  • At a civil injunction hearing, the petitioner must prove by a PREPONDERANCE of the evidence (e.g. majority of the evidence) that a respondent engaged in conduct prohibited under Florida law (Richards v. Gonzalez, 178 So.3d 451 (Fla. 3d DCA 2015))
  • At a criminal trial, the State must prove BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT that the defendant committed each and every element of the crime(s) charged 

Moreover, the issuance of a permanent injunction does not necessarily mean the injunction will actually last forever. A judge may temporally limit a final injunction to a period of years (e.g. a year, three years, five years). ‘

A permanent injunction may also be modified or dissolved if any of the following three things happen:

  • The petitioner moves VOLUNTARILY to dismiss or amend the injunction on the basis that they are no longer in fear of a respondent/the underlying circumstances have changed
  • The respondent moves to modify or dissolve the injunction on the basis that even though there may have been legally sufficient grounds for its initial issuance, there is no longer a threat to the petitioner (Hobbs v. Hobbs, 290 So.3d 1092 (Fla. 1st DCA 2020))
  • A reviewing court, such as a Florida District Court of Appeal, sets aside an injunction on the basis that there was insufficient evidence to support its issuance in the first place

At an injunction hearing or a trial where “repeat violence” has been alleged, there are typically a few key legal issues that are discussed. These include:

  • Whether the respondent’s conduct was REPEATED
  • Whether the respondent’s conduct was willful and malicious
  • Whether the respondent’s conduct had/did not have a legitimate purpose (e.g. aside from harassing a petitioner, per Khan v. Deutschman, 282 So.3d 965 (Fla. 1st DCA 2019))
  • Whether the respondent’s conduct was likely to cause an objectively reasonable person in the petitioner’s position to suffer SUBSTANTIAL emotional distress
  • Whether the respondent engaged in two or more courses of conduct that were “violent” in nature

In one Florida case involving a challenge to a permanent injunction against repeat violence, the petitioner alleged that the respondent committed two separate violent acts (approximately five to seven minutes apart), which served as the basis for the injunction.

The respondent argued to the trial judge, and to Florida’s 4th District Court of Appeal (Southeast FL’s highest court) that the evidence was insufficient as a matter of law to support the issuance of the repeat violence injunction. 

The respondent claimed that both acts of alleged “violence” arose from the same incident – and a single course of conduct cannot serve as the basis for a repeat violence injunction. The 4th DCA, however, REJECTED his claim and AFFIRMED the issuance of the permanent injunction.

But why? Let’s look at this seminal case in Florida injunction law – Levy v. Jacobs, 69 So.3d 403 (Fla. 4th DCA 2011) – and see what it means for those pursuing or defending against injunctions stemming from alleged repeat violence.

KEY CASE: Levy v. Jacobs, 69 So.3d 403 (Fla. 4th DCA 2011)

In Levy v. Jacobs, 69 So.3d 403 (Fla. 4th DCA 2011), the petitioner (Jacobs) asserted that Levy violently attacked him multiple times following an argument. At the final injunction hearing, the following was revealed:

  • Levy encountered Jacobs outside of their condominium complex on the day in question
  • For unclear reasons, the two started arguing
  • Levy approached Jacobs, cursing, then brushed his hand against Jacobs’s chest
  • Jacobs accused Levy of hitting him
  • Levy then struck Jacobs in the chest
  • Jacobs fled into the complex’s lobby, and five minutes later, Levy encountered him there 
  • The two began arguing again, and ultimately, Levy threw Jacobs to the ground
  • At the injunction hearing, Jacobs introduced images of his injuries and testimony from a valet driver who witnessed the alleged attack(s)
  • Levy DID NOT challenge the underlying claims – instead, Levy argued on a motion for a directed verdict that the “violence” was part of one continuous incident (e.g. not “repeat” violence for injunction purposes)
  • The judge DENIED Levy’s motion and granted the repeat violence injunction

On appeal to the 4th DCA, Levy asserted that the trial judge erred as a matter of law by denying the motion for a directed verdict. However, the 4th DCA REJECTED his argument and affirmed the issuance of the permanent injunction. The 4th DCA wrote:

“​​In the present case, however, competent substantial evidence supported the trial court’s conclusion that Levy’s attacks on Jacobs were separate incidents of violence. Although the two attacks occurred on the same premises, the first occurred outside the building and the second occurred inside the building. Furthermore, unlike Darrow, in this case the record evidence demonstrated that in addition to occurring in different locations, there was a temporal break of approximately five minutes between the incidents. This was a sufficient temporal break to allow Levy time to pause, reflect, and form a new intent before the second attack. Cf. Clinton v. State, 970 So.2d 412, 414 (Fla. 4th DCA 2007) (holding that no double jeopardy violation occurred where the defendant stabbed the victim, the victim walked towards a convenience store and collapsed, and the defendant then stabbed the victim again; each temporal break allowed the defendant to reflect and form a new criminal intent for each stabbing). Accordingly, the trial court could conclude that there were two separate incidents of violence in this case, rather than a single continuous incident of violence. As this was a finding of fact for which there was competent substantial evidence, we uphold the trial court’s ruling. Because this case involved “repeat violence” within the meaning of section 784.046(1)(b), there was a legal basis for the injunction. We therefore affirm.”

Put simply, the 4th DCA found there was a sufficient “temporal break” between the incidents of violence to allow Levy to reflect – and independently form the intent for the second attack. As a result, according to the 4th DCA, repeat violence had been committed.

In sum, Levy v. Jacobs, 69 So.3d 403 (Fla. 4th DCA 2011) marks a significant development in Florida’s corpus of case law surrounding final injunctions against repeat violence. The 4th DCA (Southeast FL’s highest court) held that:

  • Levy committed multiple violent acts against Jacobs, not just one
  • Though they arose from the same argument and occurred at the same location, between five and seven minutes separated the attacks
  • Levy had sufficient time to reflect before the second attack and independently form the intent to commit it (e.g. it was premeditated)
  • As a result, the trial judge was CORRECT to deny Levy’s motion for a directed verdict 
  • Accordingly, the injunction was AFFIRMED

Florida’s legal community should take note of Levy v. Jacobs, 69 So.3d 403 (Fla. 4th DCA 2011), as it makes clear that even when violent acts are committed just minutes apart, this can still be considered “repeat violence” for injunction purposes.

If someone is charged with stalking or aggravated stalking, it is critical to find experienced and trusted legal representation as soon as possible. This vital decision could make the difference in whether or not a person is subject to a lengthy prison term, hefty fines, and more.

Criminal Defense Attorney in Tallahassee, FL

Don Pumphrey, Jr. is a Former Prosecutor, Former State Police Officer, Lifetime Member of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers; for over 25 years as a private defense attorney who is Trusted, Experienced, Aggressive in Criminal Defense as a Trial Attorney, Criminal Lawyer, Criminal Defense Lawyer for the accused in Florida State Courts located in Tallahassee, Florida but handling cases throughout the State of Florida.

Don Pumphrey, Jr. and the Tallahassee criminal defense lawyers at Pumphrey Law have decades of experience fighting criminal charges on behalf of clients and winning. Call Pumphrey Law now at (850) 681-7777 to learn more about what we can do for you. Our lawyers will be happy to provide you with a free consultation.


Back to Top