UF Student Confesses to Stabbing his Mother to Death

May 2, 2024 Don Pumphrey, Jr. College, Criminal Defense, News & Announcements, Violent Crimes Social Share

Law enforcement in Polk County is trying to make sense of a targeted murder of a Florida college student’s mother. After confessing to stabbing his mother over 70 times, the medical student is facing charges of first-degree murder after claiming his motivation was due to her annoying him.

This page will provide the case details so far, as well as information pertaining to Florida homicide charges and the relative university’s code of conduct.

Case Details

On April 6, 2024, law enforcement in Polk County received a surprising call—that a 21-year-old just confessed to killing his own mother. According to one report, Emmanual Espinoza drove nearly 165 miles from the University of Florida, where he had been studying medicine. His destination was a family event in Frostproof, Florida where his mother lived.

However, when 46-year-old Elvia Espinoza answered the door to her son around 2pm while on a phone call with another family member, her son attacked her with a knife. Another report indicated that Emmanuel stabbed Elvia more than 70 times, without saying a word. Afterwards, Emmanuel called police to confess to the murder.

“We talked to him and he confessed,” said Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd. “He said, ‘You know, I have wanted to kill my mother for many, many years because she got on my nerves.’ We asked him, ‘What’s your relationship with your mother?’ and, he said about an eight out of [ten], that he really loved her, but she irritated him.”

Sheriff Judd addressed police obtained the doorbell camera footage from the day of the attack. The video showed Emmanuel approach “with a small knife in his right hand, hidden behind his back” before knocking on the front door. Emmanuel was shown wearing Air Pods during the incident, with the Kanye West song “No Church in the Wild” playing as he reached his mom’s door.

“His beautiful mother, who was so excited to see her son, opened the door,” Judd said. “The second she opened the door, he charged in and started stabbing her.”

The report indicates that Elvia attempted to run, but Emmanuel “stabbed her until she fell down and died.”

After being brought in by law enforcement, Emmanuel confessed to stabbing his mom repeatedly, even claiming that his biology classes taught him “where to stab her for maximum effect.” He said he cut himself during the incident and when he went to clean the cut and ask his mother for medicine, he realized she was dead.

The audio dispatch call Emmanuel made directly after the stabbing was played for reporters Sunday:

“I killed someone,” Emmanuel says over the phone. “I stabbed my mom.”

Elvia was a second-grade schoolteacher that was loved by all in the community, adding to the confusion.

“This is a horrible event,” Sheriff Judd said. “It’s a very sad day with an inexplicable, vicious murder.”

As far as Emmanuel’s past, law enforcement found no evidence of a criminal history, a history of mental health issues or abuse, or calls for a Baker Act. Emmanuel also told police he was not intoxicated or on any drugs at the time of the stabbing. Judd told reporters that Emmanuel was the 2020 valedictorian at his high school, known for being introverted and “described as a genius.”

The following is a statement from Sheriff Judd:

“[Elvia] wanted to come see him because she hadn’t seen him in a while. They text every day, every other day, they stay in constant contact. No issues over money. She would send him money to make sure she appropriately funded his ability to go to college and enjoy his college life. No argument that day. He never said a word to her…

I want you to understand this lady who was a school teacher for 20 years actually moved around and taught at different schools while her kids were in school so she could be close to them. I want you to understand that she was the perfect mom. I want you to understand that she was very proud of his accomplishments. The I want you to understand that he viciously murdered her and confesses to it.”

First-Degree Murder vs Second-Degree Murder

In Florida, the death of another person is broken down into the crimes of murder of the first degree, murder of the second degree, or manslaughter.

What sets murder in the first degree apart from the other crimes resulting in death is the intention. If a person previously thought out or planned the victim’s death (considered “premeditated” in legal terms), then they will face the charge of first-degree murder. On the other hand, if for example an argument between two people became heated and someone unintentionally killed the other person as a result, they can face the charge of second-degree murder.

Since Espinoza immediately called police to not only confess to his mother’s death, but to also assert that he had been “wanting to kill [his mother] for many, many years,” it is likely why he is being charged with murder in the first degree.

Important: Any criminal act that results in the death of another person will be prosecuted harshly. However, first-degree murder holds some of the toughest penalties in Florida due to the element of premeditation.

Find out more about Florida’s homicide laws on our page here.  

UF’s Code of Conduct

When individuals arrested for alleged crimes are also students with a Florida university, they can face additional consequences through the school.

Under the University of Florida’s (UF) Code of Conduct, causing physical or other harm to any person while enrolled as a UF student is considered a violation of the student code of conduct. This can include:

1. Conduct causing physical injury or endangering another’s health or safety, which includes, but is not limited to, acts of physical violence, assault, and relationship or domestic violence; or
2. Actions causing physical injury or that actually cause (and would cause a reasonable person) severe emotional distress or endangering one’s own health or safety.

Additionally, Florida Statute Section 1003.31(3) states “nothing shall prohibit a district school board from having the right to expel, or to take disciplinary action against, a student who is found to have committed an offense on school property at any time” for the following scenarios:

1. The student is found to have committed a delinquent act which would be a felony if committed by an adult;
2. The student has had adjudication withheld for a delinquent act which would be a felony if committed by an adult; or
3. The student has been found guilty of a felony offense.

To find out more about disciplinary hearings or the importance of criminal defense for college students, refer to our relative pages.

Contact a Florida College Student Defense Attorney

Accusations of murder have some of the harshest penalties in the state of Florida. These types of violent crime cases are often complex and can result in a lengthy criminal trial. That’s why it is crucial to secure top-quality legal defense for college students as soon as possible. A defense lawyer experienced in murder cases can review the evidence against you, as well as any mitigating circumstances to search for holes in the State’s case and determine if any defense strategies are available to you.

Contact the office of Pumphrey Law Firm today at (850) 681-7777 to receive a free consultation regarding your case.

  Social Share